I’ve spent more than 30 years in recruitment, and in that time the industry has reinvented itself again and again. Paper CVs became PDFs, face-to-face meetings became video calls, and rows of filing cabinets gave way to paperless offices. I’d assumed there wasn’t much left that could surprise me.

The story that changed my mind

BBC cyber correspondent Joe Tidy recently covered the case of a jobseeker who lost £18,000 of cryptocurrency savings in a single night. It began with a LinkedIn approach from someone who appeared to be a genuine recruiter. There was a real video interview, followed by what looked like a routine technical assessment: a Google Sheet with instructions attached. The candidate finished the task, went to sleep, and woke to find their wallets drained.

It wasn’t the size of the loss that stayed with me so much as how convincing the whole thing was. The cyber security researchers who looked into it found nothing that would normally raise suspicion. There were no clumsy emails or poor grammar. There was a genuine Google login, pages that looked authentic, and digitally signed software that looked like any legitimate application. One researcher said it felt like being guided through a real recruitment process from beginning to end.

I kept thinking about that story for days. Then two things happened closer to home that made it feel far less remote.

The first was a warning in my banking app. It wasn’t a general fraud notice. It was specifically about scams aimed at jobseekers.

The second came a few days later, when a candidate contacted our office simply to confirm we were genuine before going any further. I was a little surprised at first. On reflection, though, it was entirely sensible, and it shows how wary jobseekers have become.

Younger professionals are bearing the brunt

This is what worries me most, having spent my career helping people take the next step, many of them early in their working lives.

LinkedIn’s own research points to what it calls the “Gen Z scam gap”. Younger professionals are the most exposed to these scams, yet almost a third admit they’ve overlooked warning signs because the job market feels too competitive to turn anything down. As LinkedIn puts it, many young people feel they simply can’t afford to be sceptical when opportunities seem so scarce.

Picture who that really is: someone a few years into their career, without decades of instinct to draw on, keen for a break, and quietly made to feel that asking too many questions could cost them the role. That’s exactly the mindset these scammers set out to create.

This isn’t naivety. It’s the pressure of the job market being turned against the very people who have the most to lose.

What this means for employers

This isn’t only a candidate problem. Fraudsters borrow the names, logos and job titles of real businesses, and of the recruiters who represent them, because that borrowed credibility is what makes the scam work. When a candidate is targeted in your company’s name, the financial loss is theirs, but it’s your reputation that gets damaged.

There are some simple steps that help:

  • Be clear and consistent about how your hiring process works, and say so on your careers page: who will contact candidates, through which channels, and what you will never ask them to do.
  • Work with recruitment partners who are easy to verify, with a real office, a working phone line and named consultants.
  • Encourage candidates to check before they proceed, and make it easy for them to do so. A business that welcomes those questions comes across as one people can trust.

Why trust matters on both sides

Everything we do as recruiters rests on trust. Clients trust us to represent their business properly, and candidates trust us to be honest about every opportunity we put in front of them. That trust is exactly what’s being exploited: fake recruiters using genuine platforms, convincing processes and a reputation good recruiters have spent decades earning. It’s a sobering thought.

The candidate who rang to check we were real had the right idea. If there’s any doubt at all, checking should be standard practice, not an exception, and we’ll always be glad to hear from you.

If you’re looking for your next role, especially early in your career, keep these in mind:

  • A genuine recruiter will never ask you to download an app, install software or run a file in order to “complete an interview” or “receive an offer”.
  • If an assessment does involve a download, check it independently through the company’s official careers page rather than a link sent to you directly.
  • Call the agency or company directly to confirm the recruiter is who they say they are. It isn’t awkward, it’s sensible, and any legitimate recruiter will be glad you asked.
  • Be wary of urgency, such as “complete this today” or “offer expires after installation”. Real opportunities don’t depend on pressure.

After three decades in this industry, one thing is clear to me. The landscape is shifting, and whether you’re hiring or job hunting, staying alert matters more than it ever has.

Paul Harper MBA ACII Dip PFS

Managing Director, Paul Harper Search

Sources: BBC News, LinkedIn Job Search Safety Pulse