8 Jan 2015
Well, if recent reports and our survey results last year are to believed the common ground is that people lie to gain advantages that are not theirs to have.
This is a damning indictment of UKplc today. It demonstrates very clearly that if you do not qualify for something that is not by right yours, a simple little ‘white lie’ will see (that brilliant regu-phrase) a ‘positive’ outcome.
What is a positive outcome for one is a detrimental outcome for others.
The NHS has highlighted the fact that valuable resource could be saved if free prescription entitlements were more closely monitored. The somewhat archaic process of checking a box with a pen on a prescription form followed by a squiggle will result in £237m of free medication for so many beggars belief.
The NHS has form in this area. That is why so many overseas health tourists have taken the UKplc for a ride over the years. Foreign visitors and short-term migrants cost the NHS £2billion a year, an official report warned in 2013 and only around 16 per cent of the money was clawed back.
UKplc is it would seem, far too polite to question entitlements to state benefits. NHS frontline workers and pharmacists are not wishing to be involved in a few simple checks to determine entitlement because they do not see it as their responsibility.
Top state schools are having a problem too. It would seem that their popularity has seen potential student’s parents claiming postcode residency rights that they simply do not have, just to get little ‘Wayne or Waynetta’ into the school of their choice. The result is that hundreds of children have been banned from the state schools of their choice because their parents simply cheated the system to win them a place.
This is not fair on those who do have the postcode good fortune and I am pleased that at last some parents are paying the price for lying.
Now this brings me nicely on to the FOS.
Our 2011 and 2014 surveys found that adviser firms had experienced very high levels of fraudulent attempts at getting compensation. A particularly disturbing trend was the increase to the already large 2011 percentage (64%) of firms who had experienced false or manufactured accusations from complainants in an attempt to gain compensation? In 2014 it stands at 74%. The ambulance chasing section of the legal profession has not helped this situation.
If trust is to be restored in the financial services industry professional practices and moral standards, this should be matched by an injection of cynicism by the FOS.
A firm should not be treated as an “Operation Yew Tree’ suspect by the FOS where the complainant is seen to automatically be believed. Maybe that is why they need so much more office space.
We note that in November, both Mark Garnier MP and Caroline Wayman, the new FOS boss made reference to our survey in a Treasury Select Committee meeting. With 2015 well and truly here, perhaps Ms Wayman could start to act on some of our findings before even more damage is done to the industry with compensation being paid and reputations damaged when they simply should not have been.
Investigations should be based on facts not he said/ she said fishing expeditions.
And that brings me back to the NHS.
It will take until 2018 for a computer system to be available to dispensing chemists to do the appropriate checks on free prescription eligibility. In the meantime what is wrong with these outlets and indeed hospitals doing a few simple checks themselves?
This is common practice in many European countries. In Spain for example, you can forget about free treatment unless you carry an NHS card.
More requests for proof are made at a supermarket checkout to buy a bottle of wine than are asked at a chemist to fulfill a prescription order.
More time is spent on ensuring you can only buy one pack of ‘paracetomol’ so that you do not overdose yourself than on checking if someone is entitled to sometimes thousands of pounds worth of free drugs.
For financial advisers, the money laundering checks for a small ISA investment are more rigorous than check made by the NHS who are about to deliver thousands of pounds of free treatment to somebody not entitled to it.
Madness, and it’s only January.